I am writing to clarify my previous posting since I was quoted above in the main text of the initial question.
I am an MD and I have written here a few months back when I accidentally passed HSV-1 oral -to- genital to my partner. I had HSV-1 IgGs at the time this happened.
I am posting my correspondence with Dr. Anna Wald so that everyone can see what question I asked and what her expert response was. I have taken out my name from the email header. Her answers are incorporated within the text of my email:
Date: Fri, 23 Sep 2005 14:10:50 -0700 (PDT)
From: "Anna Wald" <***@****> View Contact Details Add Mobile Alert
To: "passedHVS1"
Subject: Re: a couple of questions from a fellow MD
see answers below -
On Fri, 23 Sep 2005, "passedhsv-1" wrote:
> Dear Dr. Wald,
>
> I am an Anesthesiologist in California and I hope I am
> not being too bold for emailing you directly with a
> couple of questions regarding HSV-1. I have had some
> trouble discerning which information to trust and I
> know that you are an authority on the subject matter
> given your research. I know your time is very
> valuable and I appreciate any answer you can provide.
>
> I have HSV-1 orally and serologically (IgG titer 5.1,
> HSV-2 negative). My first (that I can remember)
> outbreak was 2 months ago.
> Soon after my girlfriend contracted genital HSV-1
> (by culture) from me unfortunately (1st episode).
>
> 1. Having oral HSV-1, am I "protected" from
> contracting genital HSV-1 from my girlfriend if we
> have sex without a condom? Should we both be on
> supressive valtrex 500 mg daily?
you are mostly protected. we don't think it's a 100% but we see it
rarely in persons who have oral hsv-1. this is not a situation where
suppressive therapy would usually be recommended.
>
> This source says I would not be protected:
>
> http://herpesonline.org/hsv1vs2.html
>
> Dr. H. Hunter thinks I would be protected:
>
http://www.medhelp.org/forums/STD/messages/1438.html
>
> 2. Does having HSV-1 IgG's indicate "Immunity" from
> contracting HSV-1 at a different body site? I have had
> three recurrences of oral HSV-1 recently and I have
> been feeling tingling around the eye area the third
> time. I am worried about spreading the infection to
> myself.
no, we do not see people spread the infection around their body except
during primary infection, so no worries!
take care, anna
>
> Thank you in advance for your time in answering these
> questions.
In conclusion:
I just ask Dr. HHH to consider never telling people who have HSV-1 orally that they can not get it genitally by having genital-genital contact with a genital HSV-1 person. Please do not use the terms "you can't get it even if you tried" when giving this advice. Even the top expert in the field, Dr. Anna Wald whom you attribute 60% of your knowledge to contradicts you (see above). There are plenty of instances in this forum when this advice has been given by you and I will search them out if you want. Other frequent readers know about them also.
>