Thank you for your answer. My endo knowing I am trying to conceive has opted PTU over I-131 and is strongly against surgery. I just went down to 200mg of PTU after my level came back from 1600 to 394. I assume as my levels become more stablized my chances increase.
Graves and other autoimmune thyroid problems (Hashimoto's) do make it difficult to become pregnant. 450mg of PTU is a fairly large dose, if thyroid levels are too high or too low then preganancy is mroe difficult as well. In some cases we recommend I-131 or surgery to definitively treat the hyperthyroidism before trying to conceive. In the case of I-131, pregnancy must be delayed by at least 6 months.