Incidentally, how long have you been having unprotected sex with your boyfriend? Is this a relatively new relationship or have you had unprotected sex with him for years and not gotten pregnant?
If, at your January 29 ultrasound (would you check and see if it was really January 29? That is an assumption I threw out there and you did not confirm it), you were told that you were 7 weeks 5 days GA, that means that your conception would have been about 5 weeks 5 days previous to January 29, or around December 20. Also, when you put the estimated due date given to you by the doctor from the early ultrasound (September 12) into a conception calculator, December 20 is the date suggested by it for estimated conception date. This is just two conclusions from the same data (including the guess that the ultrasound was on January 29) but so far it suggests that the guy on the 14th was just barely too early to have produced the pregnancy. Sperm can live 4-6 days in your body, and it swims fast ("pushing it out" is way, way too late, and millions of sperm come out at one time). So you have a suggestion that the baby was not from the guy because he was too early but only by a hair's breadth.
I would go through the pregnancy assuming the baby is from your boyfriend, but would test with both guys after the baby comes so you will never have to wonder. You need to test with both guys because just getting a negative from the other guy will not really confirm it, you need to get a definite yes for one of them. And you really do not want to be party to deluding your boyfriend into raising a child that is not from him, these things have a way of coming out sooner or later, and the passage of time makes it a lot worse.
OK, so, you got the ultrasound at 7w5d; was that also when they told you the due date? And was the due date based on the baby's measurements, not on you reporting to them when your last period had come? (Was the ultrasound done around January 29?) Has the estimated due date been changed at all since then?
How early in the pregnancy did you get a due date that was from an ultrasound? Your boyfriend is having something called couvade, which is pretty cool, but I think is more to do with his sympathetic connection to you than any biological evidence that he is the father. If your due date came from a very early ultrasound, you could assume your boyfriend was the dad. But unfortunately, not if your ultrasound was much past the 7th week and not if you didn't get your due date from it.