Vera Ingrid Tarman, MD  

Specialties: food addiction, Addiction, drug addiction

Interests: Addiction Medicine, Addiction
Addictions Unplugged
Founder & Medical Director
All Journal Entries Journals
Previous | Next

Binge Eating Disorder in the DSM 5: Good News or No News for the Food Addict?

Jan 25, 2013 - 6 comments

binge eating disorder


food addiction




Phil Werdell

Binge Eating Disorder in the DSM 5: Good News or No News for the Food Addict?

For those of us working in the field of food addiction, the DSM-1V (Diagnostic and Statistics Manual) has been a poor reflection of our clinical reality. The highly controversial DSM-V, expected to be released in May 2013, may not be much of an improvement for the food addict.

Food addiction is not a medically recognized diagnosis under the DSM-1V schema. This has left dire consequences for the food addict. Without official recognition, treatment for food addiction has not been funded by any insurance provider, nor has it been offered by any major health care provider: nutritionists, dieticians, physicians have not yet recognized its existence nor proposed our recommended treatment  (abstinence from triggering addictive foods) as a healthy solution.

We have not been alone in our discontent over this diagnosis tool of the American Psychiatric Association. There has been a great deal of advocacy towards reforming the DSV-1V, and there has been ongoing controversy over the proposed DSM-Vs anticipated changes. Advocates of various hitherto excluded disorders  (such as food addicts) have attempted to get their concerns included into the psychiatric cannons of treatment, while others have been  eager to challenge the overarching ambition of psychiatry to medicalize (with the implicit intention to treat with pharmaceuticals) much of normal behaviour.  

Those working in the eating disorders field have achieved landmark success in getting "Binge Eating Disorder" recognized as a clinical entity that exists apart from Anorexia or Bulimia. This diagnosis may now include persons who suffer from the uncontrollable urge to eat large amounts of food (usually in intermittent sessions) without having to include many of the weight restricting behaviours that bulimics or anorexics engage in, i.e. vomiting, over exercise, use of laxatives. Thus many of those who are obese can now get treatment, outside of bariatric surgery, that can be funded.  

Does this help the food addict? The big question is this: Are all food addicts also suffering from binge eating disorders? While there is likely a high degree of overlap in these two groups, indeed many food addicts binge eat when in active addiction, it is important to note that they are NOT necessarily suffering from the same condition of Binge Eating Disorder. They are not the same thing. They may appear to look the same on the outside: a person overeating a large amount of food without control - but the reasons behind this behaviour are fundamentally different. The food addict is dancing to a different drummer, though the tune may look the same.

The person who is suffering from a Binge Eating Disorder is responding to social and emotional psychological cues that have disinhibited the eating behaviour. Something has prompted the person, such as previous emotional trauma stemming from childhood, sexual abuse, or current environmental stresses, to over eat in an attempt to self medicate their emotional distress.

The food addict, alternatively, is responding to the cravings created by the physical quality of food itself.  If the food addict does not pick up the first taste of sugar (or any other their trigger foods), they may not need to over eat, regardless of emotional state - calm or distressed, emotional internal or external havoc.These states of mind do  not create the overpowering drive to overeat. Certainly emotions can trigger a person to want to eat, but the control is lost truly when the food has ignited the reward pathway in the limbic brain. It is not what is eating you (Binge Eating Disorder), but what you are eating (Food addiction) that is the problem.

This distinction is important. Treatment for a person suffering from the new Binge Eating Disorder category is to heal the depression, anxiety, post traumatic stress,  so that the person does not need to self medicate with food or abnormal eating behaviours. Treatments include cognitive therapy, mindfulness and medications. They are taught how to eat all foods moderately, in the hopes that they were join "normal society" once their psychological conditions have been addressed, even resolved. The food addict, on the other hand, will never eat a "normal diet" and while psychological issues are important to sustain long term recovery, the essential first treatment for the food addict is to stop the drug that is creating the loop of addictive eating: sugar, refined starches, other trigger foods. Treatment includes abstinence from the triggering foods, peer support to encourage ongoing vigilance, and often a spiritual dimension needs to be tapped into to maintain long term recovery.

Without a diagnosis of Food Addiction, nothing much has changed with the proposed changes for 2013. We will have many food addicts funnelled under the new categorization of Binge Eating disorder, and they will probably be given treatment that could ultimately undermine their recovery. Modified diets do not work for the food addict. Advances have been made but for food addiction, still more work needs to be done.

I would like to acknowledge the painstaking work of Phil Werdell (see foodaddictioninstititute.org) for his work in lobbying the APA for food addiction's inclusion into the new DSM-V. He is a true pioneer: far sighted, dedicated and persistent.

For  more information of food addiction, see addictionsunplugged.com

Post a Comment
766573 tn?1365166466
by Idyllic, Feb 01, 2013
This is a shame. The physiological aspect food addiction has been completely ignored. What drives a binge eater is a completely different dynamic than what drives a binge eater. As one who is in recovery for substance abuse (also in remission with an ED) the distinction could not be more clear.

Avatar universal
by Dianna51, Feb 03, 2013
I have read that Binge Addiction is caused by loss of Dopamine which controls the bodies reward system.  I have Young Adult Parkinson's disease (YOPD).  Dopamine is a neuron that stimulates the reward system in the body.  It makes you feel euphoric.  When you fall in love, it is the high production of dopamine that makes you feel happy and special.  Dopamine is the opposite of adrenline.  When your 5 senses sence danger you have an adrenalin rush.  Your heartbeat quickens, your focus strenghthens to prepare you to cope with the perceived.  When you know the danger is past, dopamine is triggered to bring your heartbeat to a normal level, and calm your mental and normalize your focus.  When a person has YOPD, they are more likely to develope binge eating disorder because they no longer have a reward system to control their desire for rewards.  they eat lots of sugery and other "comfort foods" in an attempt to feel the reward system that no longer is there.  The ONLY way to treat this is by dialectical behaivior therapy.  The person must be aware of their problem (mindful) and talk to themselves to make wise food choices.   Foods high in  amino acids help protect the dopamine neurons that produce tyrosine.  It is a very hard role to take on.  Is their a medical therapy that will strenghten your resolve?  I have read that Hypobarid Oxygen therapy will help the brain recover from the damage of  oxygen damage.  Is this true?

2169060 tn?1337631232
by Vera Ingrid Tarman, MDBlank, Feb 03, 2013
Hi Dianna

If you are interested in trying the addiction approach, then not eating sugars and starches will keep the dopamine parthway intact since these foods ambush the reward pathway. You might find  that will settle the urges somewhat.

Dr Tarman

1477025 tn?1377468141
by Donna10112, Feb 06, 2013
I don't feel that my binge eating is related to addiction to food.  For me it's triggered by self-hatred and self-loathing.  It occurs after I've suffered a disappointment or rejection.  I use binging as a way of punishing myself for not being "good enough".  The behavior started when my first marriage ended in 1998.  I remarried and 3 years into that marriage, my husband began drinking and would then yell at me that none of his relatives liked me.  I found out later that was true.  I have FMS, CFS and CMP along with chronic neck pain and they couldn't understand why I wasn't working and got moody when we traveled.  His verbal abuse continued and eventually I took an overdose.  I stopped breathing in the ambulance but they saved me.  I now still, eat when I am lonely, rejected, and disappointed.  This last spring I went on a binge of ice cream, cookies, doughnut (sp) holes, Little Debbies, and chocolate.  A couple of months later, I had a toxic reaction to the yeast from the sugar and it attacked my Central Nervous System.  It took me 7 weeks of the right suppliments to get through it.  I was doing OK until I broke my ankle at the end of the 7 weeks.  Now it's hard to cook, my attitude isn't the greatest, (I forgot to mention my husband quit drinking), but I sit alone at nights eating.  Actually, after the toxic period, I'm having a hard time tolerating eating over 50 carbs a day.  I feel hopeless at the moment, but I know I have a lot of behavior to change.  

1640056 tn?1362508710
by nan1953, Mar 06, 2013
One book I read was "Get out of that Pit" by Beth Moore.  You migt consider this book as a beginning to removing the self hate feeling.Exercise, all you can, to help your condition.  There is a neck brace I use for my neck pain called "ReLeaf" and I forgot which website had it, but it is black, and just looks more like a high collar.  I hope things get better for you.

2169060 tn?1337631232
by Vera Ingrid Tarman, MDBlank, Mar 06, 2013

Just to add one more piece - purging does give an 'endorphin' rush much like other self mutilating behavours such as cutting and slashing. Stopping the sugars, starches and purging, after the 'detox' of a few weeks might help remove the cravings and desire. It is worth a try.

Post a Comment