Those other meds are over the counter. Worth a try before you see your doc, so you can tell them you tried this and for how long.
The medication was a PPI, Prevacid. There was no change, although I have never experienced heartburn or a reason to take a PPI besides the lump feeling. I will ask about the other medications as well. Also the problem is only on the right side of my throat, always in the same spot and feels solid. Thanks for the help.
What kind of GERD treatment? proton pump inhibitors? if you take those in the morning, you can consider using acid blockers at night, such as Pepcid, Zantac, Tagamet. Go back and ask if these can help. The feeling that goes away then "bobs" back up sounds like post-nasal drip, ask an allergist for help.
I also wanted to mention that pushing on my throat on the area where you would normally take a pulse makes the lump feeling more pronounced. The feeling goes away for a split second when swallowing and feels like it "bobs" back up. I also take sleeping medication nightly (lunesta) as the constant need to swallow or clear my throat prevents me from sleeping.