I have always loved Anastasia
Andrea, Alexianna, Adrian, Adriana, Ashton, Ameilhia(Amelia), Anniston, Arrianna, or Aspen :-)
Anna-Marie, Addison, Amber, Angelic, Annalise, Audrey, Amelia, Anastasia
That's all I can think of right now, my mom named us all starting with A names as well 3 girls.
Good Luck and Congrats :-)
I like Abigail too. Or Abby for short.
I think the name Annabelle is cute
My daughters name is Avery...not too common