What i did was make goodie bags...I bought à bunch of brown bags and went to the dollar store and just bought a whole bunch of random things (toothbrush, wallet, sponge etc) and divided all of them into the bags. And the winner of the game got to choose which bag they wanted.
I gave like candles, lotions, hand soap/hand towel, pens/note pad, chocolates...
people seemed to like them.
Check out bath and body works they always do really good sales on lotions hand soaps or even their candles
For my baby shower we gave out amazing smelling candles from Burts bees and scented bath soaps!
For my brothers and probably what I'll do for mine was a bit of everything. $5 gift cards, lotions, candles, I make homemade soap, sweet treats. Things like that
i went to bath and body works... right now they have a 50-75 % sale. and lotions with body soap will be good game prizes... :) and hand sanitizers
I did bath salts, bubble bath, face scrubs, and candles
I went to bath and body works , they have alot of really good smelling body sprays and lotion etc for a good price !