This is a common situation -- the reason we look at TSH is that a low TSH is associated with increased risk of atrial fibrillation (a potentially lethal heart rhythm problem) -- think of it as having high cholesterol....you feel fine now, but we treat the high cholesterol to decrease the chance of a heart attack.
The TSH level of <0.2 is usually where we want to lower the thyroid replacement dosage. The other risk of a low TSH is osteoporosis.
That being said, everyone is different and if our bodies came with instructions that included the ideal TSH level for each individual, that would make things much simpler. A TSH around 1.0 is what most non-thyroid diseased individuals have.
In your case a TSH of 38.8 is very high for the 175mcg compared to 0.01 for the 200mcg dose -- either there was an absorption issue, a generic/brand issue, an interfering med or inconsistency with the medication.
In this case, I have sometimes asked patients to take one pill six days a week and then one-half pill the seventh, but to stay on the higher dose. Work with your doctor to keep your treatment safe and effective.
I think everyone has an optimal range maybe,I too feel better(no joint or muscle pains) at a low tsh but my doc says NO!!!! Even with my free t's labs in the upper range, but in range, my doc increased my Tapazole, now I'm hypo(bottom of range) and have muscle pains, can't there be a happy medium? Why do most people FEEL better hyper?Why do doctors hate that low tsh, but if it's high they really don't treat it half the time?Please enlighten us doctor Lupo!!!