When is it time for surgery instead of a chiropractor?

[Lisa303]

I am a 44 year old woman with a history of neck and back pain.  X-Rays were confirmed by several docs that I have a 6th lumbar vertabrae with partial sacralization.  Four years ago I began having a new dull lower back pack that shot down my left leg and around my hip.  If I walked too much it actually felt like my back was going to give out and I'd fall.  Bending down to put on a boot, I felt a "pop" and I experienced a shooting pain in my back and down my left leg.  When I tried to stand, my leg gave out.  My husband took me to the chiropractor in INTENSE mind-blowing pain.  Everywhere they touched me hurt.  It was the most unbearable pain I've ever experienced.  (And I've had 3 children).  Without doing an MRI, the chiropractors made the assumption that I had a bulging disc and they could get me back into shape.  I was due to go on vacation the next day, so I went to my MD who gave me muscle relaxants and pain killers.  I laid on my back for a week in Mexico and when I returned I was about 50%.  With about two more weeks of chiropractic care, I was back to normal.  

I experience constant back pain which for the most part I can live with.  I do however, have massive pain if I garden, rake, vaccuum or do anything that puts a strain on my lower back.  I am a very active individual and I can't accept the fact that I will have this disabling pain for the rest of life which only seems to be worsening.  I usually end up "on my back" unable to work for a week out of the year.

Is this something that can/should be treated with surgery?

[Suri123]

Hi Lisa303, how are you doing? I do agree with Zak_Han for saying not to rush for surgery until it is indicated. Thanks Zak_Hav for your thoughts. You may consult a orthopedic doctor and get an physical examination done and if necessary a MRI low back which can better let you know the cause and the degree of severity. You need to discuss in detail with the surgeon plan of care. Not all backaches land up in surgery. Chiropractic treatment might take a long time. Do share your thoughts and take care.

[Zak_Han]

only 2% back pain cases need surgery and there are have a lot of FBSS (fail back surgery syndrome) suffers.so don't rush to surgery if alternative med can help.
I think :Most important is keeping activity,a lot of walking,stronger back muscle,keep warming,
Good luck!