Instead of playing a game at mine we are decorating onies and bibs. Using fabric paint and letter transfers and also the transfer paper with fabric. We are kind of crafty people in my family so it seemed like more fun to us than games.
This was my favorite!
http://www.babyshower101.com/baby-traits-game.pdf
There's a lot of really fun games out there. There's this one where you have teams of two and they have to build a diaper out of toilet paper on the other in so much time. Then there's this one where they have to eat baby food and guess the flavor of what they're eating.
I'm my sure what this game is called but I played this at my baby shower in February were you melt chocolate put it in a diaper and have to smell it and guess what chocolate it is. I thought it was fun and made everyone laugh, there wasn't a dull moment.
We played one at mine where you had to make a baby out of play dough while blindfolded in 90 seconds and then voted on the best one, the winner got a prize basket.
My aunt had one one time where the men were forced to go and some games they had to include them they put beer/soda pop in a baby bottle and whoever chugged all of it first won. It was fun to watch lol
With my first baby shower we played the candy bar game.... it was so much fun. Each candy name represents something that has to do with baby like... 100 grand (doctor bill) chunky (10lbs baby) twix (twins) butterfinger (clumsy doctor) three musketeer (triplets) sex life after baby (zero)....you get the idea best game ive ever played!