Dear bestinfo: Based on the information you have provided, your friend does not have cancer. A papilloma is a benign tumor. It can be removed with a simple outpatient procedure - just to be certain that it is only a papilloma. The pathology of atypical hyperplasia may increase your friend's risk of developing cancer in the future. Based on this information a good follow-up plan for monitoring will likely be recommended.
That is great news. Perhaps I misunderstood.
thank you so much for your valuable time...
she is going into a Dr. Witt at Rush in Chicago to ask for a Second opinion on the pathology report and the DX.
What are the Exact questions she should ask the Dr. for the second opinion?
Thanks!
Then why did the Dr. say it was malignant? and What exactly is invloved in getting this removed?
Best info
a papilloma is a common tumor in the breast; it is not cancer. The other terms describe what the cells look like, and are not rare in papillomata. It might or might not correlate with some increased risk of getting cancer in the future, but not enought to do anything about except maintain a regular program of surveillance (exams, mammograms). Most people would recommend complete removal of the papilloma, rather than just biopsy, in order to be sure there's nothing more there, and to prevent it from growing more.
Sounds like there's some misunderstanding here: what you have quoted does not constitute malignancy. Where the misunderstanding lies, I can't say: either she misunderstood the doctor, you misunderstood her, or there's more in the report. Removing the tumor when it's not palpable requires an xray doctor placing a guidewire into the area -- a procedure usually simpler than the biopsy she already had -- following which she goes to surgery for removal, which the surgeon does by making an incision and following the wire to the area. Or, depending on circumstances, it might be done without the wire, if it's felt that the duct in which the papilloma lies can be found and removed directly.