Your GP is right about swabbing a blister being the best way to diagnose HSV. A "positive" swab is conclusive. Unlike blood-testing, where a positive value (IgG) of between 1.1 - 3.5 is actually a negative reading 50% of the time, assuming that the testing was taken 3-4 months after the last possible exposure to the virus.
The experts I have followed on this recommend getting swabbed within 48 hours of the appearance of a blister for accurate swab results. Getting liquied may be sufficient for testing purposes; but, I have yet to read anyone saying that specifically.
No one has any info or comments? :(