Such symptoms are especially unlikely with a primary HSV infection; most claims about such prolonged symptoms come from people with longstanding recurrent herpes. I believe there is no chance that herpes lesions will appear. You need to start looking to other causes for your symptoms; it isn't herpes.
Thanks again, final Q's. I don't mean to make you repeat yourself but I came here 'cause I truly value your professional opinion, so just to clarify. In your opinion and experience, extended weeks of leg pain cannot be a herpes primary outbreak? Do you think there is a chance these pains will stop and then a lesion will appear?
Those simply are not reliable reports. Such beliefs by patients are common but simply not supported by any data. Trust me on this: you did not catch herpes. Re-read my comments above.
From all you have said so far, the advice you have had from the SHC ("STI clinic") sounds right. If you visit the Sydney SHC, do not expect to hear anything different than you have already had.
thanks for the reply. I'm not in a major city but frequent Sydney on business regularly so will seek out more advise.
What remains a concern is the many sites/forums where people with genital herpes complain of neurological pains that last weeks/months/years. The symptoms they claim are so similar to mine its frightening. I am certain what I feel is nerve related.
Welcome to the STD forum. I'll try to help. Bottom line: Almost certainly you acquired neither herpes nor any other STD from the oral sex event. Herpes does not cause the symptoms you describe.
Since you're from Australia, I assume that "STI clinic" means one of your country's excellent sexual health centres. Collectively, your SHCs are probably the world's best network of STD/HIV clinics, and if you're in a major metropolitan area -- e.g. Sydney or Melbourne -- you have been to the best of the best. There is not a thing about STDs that I know any better than they do.
You were correctly informed that HSV-2 is not acquired by oral sex. There may be rare transmissions of HSV-2 from mouth to genitals, but for practical purposes the only risk is for HSV-1. You also were correctly informed that since you have had oral herpes, you are immune to a new HSV-1 infection. So on these grounds alone, herpes is not a feasible explanation for your symptoms.
Finally, as I'm sure you were also told by one or more of the professionals you have seen, whether at the SHC or elsewhere, herpes does not cause symptoms like you describe. Lists of herpes symptoms, see such things as thingling, numbness, "tightness", or other aches and pains in various parts of the body. However, such lists usually do not make clear that these things do NOT occur with herpes in the absence of standard herpes outbreaks, i.e. blisters, sores, etc. A herpes outbreak may tingle or burn, and some outbreaks are preceded for 1-2 days by localized neurological symptoms (called a "prodrome") like tingling, burning, etc. But that's all. Finally, herpes symptoms never are continuous; they last a few days, then go away entirely until the next outbreak, and outbreaks never happen more often than every 6 weeks or so.
For all these reasons, I agree with the advice you have had; and I trust their expertise in herpes. I also would not recommend HSV testing in this circumstance. If you do it, the results might be more confusing than helpful. If negative, it will simply confirm what we already know, i.e. that your symptoms aren't herpetic. And if positive, it will mean you have asymptomatic herpes plus another explanation for your symptoms. So what's the point?
The advice to "move on and seek therapy" suggests your SHC provider believes your symptoms are psychogenic, perhaps reflecting genitally focused anxiety -- which is quite common after sexual exposures about which patients feel regret, shame or guilt. Here too I am in agreement.
I hope this helps. Best wishes-- HHH, MD