So what if the condom protection factor is only 80%? Or 50%? Re-read my reply above. Even if you take the condom completely out of the picture, the risk remains near zero.
You came here for reassurance, presumably. I gave it. Accept it and move on. Truly, the risk is not significant.
The risk you caught HSV-2 is exceedingly low, if not quite zero. Among herpes-discordant couples (one partner with HSV-2, the other without) who are in regular relationships, having unprotected sex an average of 2-3 times per week, the annual risk of HSV-2 transmission is 5%, i.e. 1 in 20 susceptible partners is infected. So the average risk calculates to somewhere around 3 per 1,000 episodes of sex. In your situation, you add the condom (>90% protection) and your partner taking valtrex (at least 60% protection), and it takes you into the astronomically low range.
To put this into perspective (and not to frighten you for a different reason): If you live in the US, statistically there is 1 chance in 1,756 that you will be dead a year from today because of some accident (auto wreck, a fall, drowning, etc, etc). The chance you caught herpes is a lot lower than that.
The most commonly used HSV antibody test is usually positive by 2 months, but it takes up to 3-4 months in at least 10-20% of cases. I really don't recommend testing at all in this circumstance, as long as you remain symptom free. (The zit you describe sounds just like that, a zit. Herpes is uncommon in hair bearing areas anyway.) If you get tested and are positive, probably it would be from sometime other than the exposure events you desribe here.
I hope this helps. The bottom line is that you have no serious worries here.
Regards-- HHH, MD
Yes, as I was driving home I thought about my second question and I was going to write another telling you to forget it, you did indeed address that concern already. Like I said, paranoid by nature. Thanks very much for your guidance.
Even though the condom came off for about a minute? I would think my >90% protection factor would drop greatly, but I'm paranoid by nature too. We were engaged in intercourse at the time, not too vigorously but not too lightly either. Just kinda regular, I guess.
Thank you, doctor.