TSH is a pituitary hormone, not a thyroid hormone. Usually people with Hashimoto's don't feel well until TSH is suppressed and the frees are in the upper 1/3 of the range, not the middle. Find an endo who treats your symptoms, not your TSH. You are hypo. Your facial swelling, eyebrows, etc. 50 mcg of Synthroid is a starter dosage. You need more. I started on 50. I'm now on 125, soon to be bumped, and 5 mcg of Cytomel.
Every time I get hypo symptoms, I call my endo and let him know. He writes me a higher prescription just based on my symptoms. Most endos aren't that liberal, but find someone who will at least treat the frees, not the TSH.
:) Tamra
P.S. My TSH has been maintaining around a 2 and my other levels are dead middle of normal lab ranges.