Custer was probably more bipolar the Lee, course it could be a ploy to make us feel better. Then again, in times past you could follow grandious ideas, not so much these days.
Beeper, I like that name for bipolar. Sounds less "medical". We are all a closely knit group here and I really appreciate the support and comfort I receive from all the people on these message boards. Thanks to all of you.
Ruby
Society in the past was not as intolerant of abberant behavior as it is now. With half the poeple walking around with some type of chronic illness, mental or physical, a high functioning bi-polar person was not much to notice.
Also, the lens of history attempting to diagnose these people after a century or more is cloudy at best. Very little evidence supports that the modern mental health community can diagnose modern people correctly better than half the time.
Lincoln had a hard life. Robert E Lee valiantly fought a war based on a complex split loyalty and he knew that victory was almost without hope. You'd have a hard time convincing me that a man in his position, after a Chancellorsville, was faulty in ordering Pickett's Charge.
I've seen these diagnoses of historical figures. The mountainous ego it must take for an obscure nobody to second-guess the greatest among us through the ages. LOL
Also Van (Brown Eyed Girl) Morrison....Vincent Van Gogh.....and from what I heard Eric Clapton
btsmith
Am so glad I could help. Many many famous ppl in history are bpers. Look at all they accomplished. And without good meds!! Amazing, huh?
Thats so cool! You just made me feel a little better.