Aa
Aa
A
A
A
Close
Avatar universal

Kim Davis and this lady.....

http://www.breitbart.com/big-government/2015/09/02/geller-muslim-stewardess-refuses-to-serve-alcohol-then-plays-the-victim/

Kim Davis who refuses to sell marriage licenses and this lady, Charee Stanley, refuses to sell alcohol as a flight attendant.  The discussion around the office was, what makes them different and what makes them similar?  

What makes them different is one was an elected official.  What makes them similar is they are both shirking some of their responsibilities.  One argument that was brought up here regarding Miss Davis is, selling gay marriage licenses was not part of her duty.  That's a pretty good argument but I had to ask, how many times have you had to take on more responsibilities within your own job?  (Me?  Ever since I started working some 34 years ago.)

The muslim flight attendant....  How could you not know that selling alcohol would not be part of your job?  What else do they do?  The little pre-flight speech, hand out complimentary non-alcoholic beverages, sell alcohol, and make sure everyone has their seat belt fastened....  

Do all that is required.  Do all that is expected of everyone else in your position.  If you can't do that or won't do that, do the honorable thing and step down.

I hope davis is impeached and I hope they throw the muslim lady off the tarmac.
19 Responses
Sort by: Helpful Oldest Newest
Avatar universal
She can facilitate being impeached.  In fact, she has but I don't think anyone will pull the trigger.  Lots of big bible folks down there.
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
She's an elected official, has to resign or be impeached.
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
Do the job as described or hit the bricks.  
Helpful - 0
649848 tn?1534633700
Why do they always try to make the Muslim right and the Christian wrong, when they're both wrong?  Just because the airline stewardess is not an elected official and serving alcohol is not a "central duty" doesn't mean there's no comparison.  There are many other duties for a clerk of court, so issuing marriage licenses may not be a "central duty" for her, either...
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
Muslim Flight Attendant Says She's Suspended For Not Serving Alcohol

A Muslim flight attendant for ExpressJet is fighting to be reinstated after she says the airline suspended her for refusing to serve alcohol.

In a complaint filed last week with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Charee Stanley said the carrier had revoked a reasonable arrangement made to accommodate her religious beliefs.

Stanley's lawyer, Lena Masri of the Council on American-Islamic Relations' Michigan chapter, told The Huffington Post Monday that Stanley approached her superiors in June about how she could avoid serving alcohol to passengers because she recently discovered that Islamic law forbids it.

The airline told her to make a deal with fellow flight attendants so they could provide the beverages, Masri said. The arrangement seemed to be working smoothly until a coworker complained to the airline in early August that Stanley had been delinquent in her duties because she refused to serve the cocktails. The complaint also noted that Stanley "had a book with foreign writings and wore a headdress," CNN wrote.

In late August the airline notified Stanley, an employee of three years who became a Muslim about two years ago, that the accommodation had been revoked. ExpressJet placed her on unpaid leave for 12 months, Masri said. She was also threatened with termination, the lawyer added.

In an interview with HuffPost on Monday, the airline said it could not comment on personnel matters, but offered the following statement: "We embrace and respect the values of all of our team members. We are an equal opportunity employer with a long history of diversity in our workforce."

Masri told HuffPost that Stanley was open to mediation, but if no satisfactory solution is reached, she and her client would consider a lawsuit. In the meantime, Stanley was seeking other employment, the attorney said.

Responding to parallels drawn to the case of Kim Davis, the Kentucky clerk who cited her religious beliefs in refusing to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples, Masri said there was no comparison.

Stanley is not a public official, she said. She emphasized that Stanley's request to accommodate her faith was "not at the expense of anyone else." As instructed by her employer, she reached an accord with colleagues so passengers could still get their drinks.

"She got suspended for following the directions," Masri said to HuffPost, adding that "serving alcohol is not a central duty of being a flight attendant."

In summing up the conflict, the attorney told CNN that Stanley was fighting for basic rights: "What this case comes down to is no one should have to choose between their career and religion and it's incumbent upon employers to provide a safe environment where employees can feel they can practice their religion freely."
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/muslim-flight-attendant-says-shes-suspended-for-not-serving-alcohol_55ed9963e4b002d5c07652c2
Helpful - 0
163305 tn?1333668571
Hey guess what, I agree with Vance !

Kim Davis actually can let someone below her issue the licenses. If that is so objectionable to her then she needs to resign~ simple.
And yes, the Muslim woman took on a job that includes serving alcohol. She can change positions or quit.  
Since she's not drinking I don't really see what her problem is but then again, I don't see the problem with issuing gay wedding licenses either.

A close friend who went through a rigorous Christian upbringing insists there is nothing in the bible that mentions homosexuality.
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
Kim Davis needs to follow the law, she may not like it but all of us follow laws we don't like. Either she follows the law or resigns/gets fired. I see people on social media saying she is standing up for what she believs in and if she was a liberal she would commended. I say whatever to those people. She has a job to do so do it. She wants to yell and scream from a soapbox while off duty so be it. But when at her job do what the job requires or find a new job.

The muslim should either perform her duties or move to flights that do not serve alcohol (but i bet there is a pay cut and she will complain about that) or she finds a new job.

It's that simple for both people.
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
That's how I feel about a lot of Christians. There are a lot of good ones out there and they outweigh the disillusioned hypocritical jack wagons.
Helpful - 0
1747881 tn?1546175878
"Both these women just recently found religion."

So have half the people in your nearest county jail !!!   BFD

That's the problem with organized religion, if you don't believe their way then it's the wrong way.
Helpful - 0
649848 tn?1534633700
Both of these women are giving religion a bad name.  They are both entitled to their beliefs, but they are not entitled to force others to adhere to their beliefs and that's where we're running into so much trouble in this country... some people think that everyone else is required to believe as they do - that's not so and they need to get over it.
Helpful - 0
2059648 tn?1439766665
Both these women just recently found religion.   This is the excuse for their actions.  
Helpful - 0
1747881 tn?1546175878
My thought is quit being difficult and work it out, if you want to keep your job there are options, if not, hit the bricks.
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
Thin about this for a second.  Kim Davis's ancestors probably left Europe because of religious persecution, but now she is trying to force her religion on other people?  

It might not have been part of her job to issue licenses to gay people, but it is now.  Issue them or step down.  I don't think the woman knows anything about honor.  Besides that, am I the only person in the country to sign on to a position with specific duties only to have more duties added on?  I'm guessing no.....  If you don't like the work situation, get out of it or do the damned job.

About "going down with the ship".  Not part of the job description, but there is a potential of something like that happening.  12-16 hour shifts?  Waaaaaa , Cry me a river.  Don't like it, step down.  No sitting around complaining.  

The flight attendant signed on to a job that required her to sell alcohol.  She took that job completely understanding the rules and the proof is that she did the job for a while before taking a stand....  She should be fired or moved to a position where selling alcohol is not part of the job description, like loading bags or working the counter.
Helpful - 0
649848 tn?1534633700
When you take a job, you agree to perform the duties that go with go with that job, whether you like them or not... The airline stewardess knew that alcohol was served on most airlines.  Granted, perhaps she could serve on an airline that doesn't serve alcohol, but shirking her duty on one that does serve alcohol, by having co-workers serve the alcohol should not be an option.

New duties are often added to a job description after one has taken the job, and if you don't like them, the recourse, is, typically, to quit the job... granting marriage licenses to same sex couples is a new duty that was added to Kim Davis' job description via the Supreme Court... She doesn't have the right not do her job or to prevent the employees that work under her and are willing to grant said marriage licenses, from doing their jobs even if she's unwilling to do hers.  Her option is to step down from her job.  In the long run, she serves no purpose for martyring herself by sitting in jail...  
Helpful - 0
2059648 tn?1439766665
Kim Davis doesn't want any of the government employees working under her to issue same sex marriage licenses.   She does have to personally issue the licenses.   There are ways to accommodate the stewardess by having another persons serve the  alcohol.  

But by saying I'm not allowing anyone else to do it either is the issue with the elected official.  She appointed herself as a judge which she is not.  

Get over Kim Davis.   She's not God either!
Helpful - 0
1029273 tn?1472231494
Well, you made the first point clear that Kim Davis is an elected official ~ she's serving time now, until either she will agree to the licensing; is impeached, or until the end of her term. Charee Stanley started working 3yrs. ago for the airline, then converted to Islam 2 yrs. ago.  She claims, it wasn't until this year that she realized her faith doesn't allow her to drink alcohol, and serve it too...
So, back to your point, Davis selling marriage licenses to same sex couples was not part of her duties when she was elected into service. Stanley entered into a work agreement as an attendant who would be serving alcohol during flights. That's the difference.

Not all flights serve alcohol anymore; perhaps Stanley can be scheduled there. Muslim airlines don't serve alcohol; Stanley would probably be happier serving there...

What else do flight attendants do? They make sure you're comfortable during flights by serving you. Often they have to act as first responders during passenger emergencies. They work long shifts, sometimes 12 to 16 hours,usually living away from home. If the plane crashes, they go down with the ship...
Helpful - 0
649848 tn?1534633700
No story, just a photo?  Or am I missing something? Wouldn't be unusual... lol
Helpful - 0
148588 tn?1465778809
http://www.theonion.com/graphic/christian-science-pharmacist-refuses-to-fill-any-p-9645

And yeah, I know it's The Onion.
Helpful - 0
649848 tn?1534633700
I expect Davis to be impeached, but I'd guess the Muslim lady will win, in some way, just like others have won...
Helpful - 0
You must join this user group in order to participate in this discussion.

You are reading content posted in the Current Events . . . Group

Didn't find the answer you were looking for?
Ask a question
Popular Resources
A list of national and international resources and hotlines to help connect you to needed health and medical services.
Herpes sores blister, then burst, scab and heal.
Herpes spreads by oral, vaginal and anal sex.
STIs are the most common cause of genital sores.
Condoms are the most effective way to prevent HIV and STDs.
PrEP is used by people with high risk to prevent HIV infection.