Does the jurisdiction where you live have legislation regarding individual access to their own personal and medical information?
In Alberta, patients are entitled to obtain any documentation pertaining to themselves on their own medical files, under the Health Information Act. This applies to whomever holds this information, whether they be public agencies or private organizations. Other provinces have similar laws. This is akin to the various information and privacy laws, but specific to medical records.
There are certain types of information that may be exempted from the act and legally not made available to an individual, but typically only when the disclosure of such information could cause harm to the individual or compromise the privacy of a third party, etc. Here in Alberta, physician notes of a particular patient would typically be expected to be disclosed to that patient upon request, unless such an exemption applied. If the holder of the information does not cooperate, requests can be made for one's own information through formal channels. One must first demonstrate that they attempted to access their own records directly, so if the physician won't hand them over on a verbal request, you should send the office a letter being as specific as you can in about the information you want (ie; which records done on what date, etc.)
Fees may be charged for providing copies of records but only a reasonable amount to cover the cost of producing the copies, nothing more. Again, this applies in Alberta; I'm not sure about other provinces/states.
Perhaps similar laws exist where you live that provide you the right to access the info you are seeking.
db1
I recently got my records from the first neuro I saw (he retired) and he would not give me the records from neuro #2 which were in my file because he hadn't "signed" them. He said they would be sent to any new doctor I went to, but seemed to imply that he could not give me as the patient the records that came from another doctor so maybe you would have to go back to those old doctors directly. I did get the reports he wrote to my pcp, but not the handwritten exam notes (though I probably couldn't have interpreted much of those anyway based on the other ones I've seen).
I'm sorry you had to pay so much for stuff that was useless. That's happened to me in other situations when trying to get records.