meniscus surgery

[boulderhiker]

After a recent fall, MRI showed a small tear near the free edge or the posterior horn and body of the medial meniscus- the orthopedist feels that without surgery it will get worse.  This is a workman's comp so don't think I can wait and see and hope that if it does get worse they will cover an operation several years later.  Wondering if surgery really is necessary, not sure if it is in the red-red zone or red-white zone.  If I do surgery what is realistic for recovery time?

[boulderhiker]

Thanks for your reply, Dr. Kaul
After a recent small hike the knee is a little worse.  I think I will go get a second opinion.

[S. Kaul, MD]

Hi there!

Well, without a detailed clinical evaluation it would be difficult to comment on if surgery would be required at this stage or would be the best option. While minor tears are usually managed conservatively, surgery may be required in a few cases. You may consider seeking a second opinion with another orthopedician at this time, to be certain of the appropriate management plan.
Hope this is helpful.

Take care!