I think Paige sounds great!
I was already thinking Marie. Its on my list for a middle name as well. Meilani Marie Fisher. Meilani Claire Fisher. Meilani Paige Fisher. Melanie Grace Fisher. Those are some but there's a lot more. You don't want the middle name to be a vowel since the last letter of the first name is a vowel. If its a girl for me the first name ends in an A so I'm in the same situation.
What's the baby's last name if you don't mind me asking? I don't know the what my baby is but I'd rather have names picked out and its easier with a first and last name to find a middle.