Personally I think using a stop smoking aide that keeps nicotine in your system, interferes with the mental mindset necessary to successfully end the addiction.
Why?
Because addiction has two components that are both addicting. One is the Mental or psychological reasons we smoke, which are all different for each of us individually. Secondly, the physical side of nicotine that interferes with our blood sugar levels, ability to deal with stress, the part that actually alters physically the way our bodies are meant to work. When we use gum for instance. we are not doing the act of lifting hand to mouth, but are still feeding the body the nicotine to avoid the shock of withdrawels, while we concentrate on the habit side of it all. We fill that side with hard candy, paperclips, fake cigs or whatever we can to avoid that mental void that laying them down brings about.
For some people, they have been successful by cutting down. This never worked for me, cause the minute my life took a turn or if I was in a setting with someone who smoked, my reseverve totally went out the window, and the thoughts of cutting down make me want them even more, same if someone told me I should quit, it made me want them even more, so you see the physcological side is as strong or in my opinion stronger than the physical addiction itself. Some of course would disagree, and I speak soley from personal perspective here.
I have seen people become addicted to the gum, because they shifted that dependency to it instead of the cigarettes in much the same way as someone who chews tobacco.
In my opinion, if your thinking of quitting. You know it is not going to be easy right? So if you have the choice of paying more money for a third party to help you out over several weeks and months, or go cold and have the nasty stuff out of you system in 72 hrs, why would you not opt to get it out and be done with it? It is the time and success gained by going the 72 hr route that gives you the incentive to move on. I have saved 175.00 in three weeks. I simply transfer this money from buying a carton to my personal savings. If I fail, I have to return the money to the budget. As long as I am smoke free I get to keep that money for something I want. Think about it! I am not feeling deprived cause I am rewarding, or paying myself for my success.