While anything is *possible, it's hardly *probable* that this an "anomaly"... First off, the highest reference range I've ever seen for TSH is 5.50 and while some doctors believe that it's okay to let TSH get as high as 10, which is totally crazy, I've never heard of one taking a "wait and watch" approach when TSH is higher than 10... Many people have hypo symptoms with a TSH of much less than 5.50 and many labs have a much lower reference range, plus it's been recommended that the reference range only go as high as 3.0.
Secondly, if your doctor is only testing TSH, that's a good indication that he's not a good thyroid doctor. TSH is a pituitary hormone and often, does not adequately represent actual thyroid hormone status. You should insist that he test Free T4 and Free T3, as well, in order to get the full picture.
The thyroid produces T4 and T3, but mostly T4. Of that T4, most is bound by a protein and can't be used, which is why we test for Free (unbound) T4. Free T4 isn't used, directly, but must be converted to T3. Like T4, most of the T3 in your body is bound by protein and can't be used, so again, we test for Free (unbound) T3. Free T3 is the hormone that's used by nearly every individual cell in your body.
Thyroid hormones control metabolism (hence, your weight), body temperature, heart rate and other body functions.
Other symptoms, besides weight gain/inability to lose, commonly found with hypothyroidism include, but are not limited to constipation, fatigue, muscle/joint aches/pains, hair loss, facial puffiness, swelling/edema, depression, anxiety, brain fog, etc. There are actually many more symptoms that a lot of us don't even think to associate with hypothyroidism.