start off with the plastic applicators- just remember not to flush them! go for the smallest ones to start with- and change them as necessary for your flow. don't worry about TSS, it's not as common as the warnings scare you to believe... yes, you will feel it as you're pushing it inside, but you won't feel it the whole time it's in there- the funny feeling only lasts for a bit. if you don't think you're ready to make the switch, then give yourself time.
Okay since you're not used to using tampons, use plastic applicators next time. when i first started using tampons it felt a little uncomfortable too, i could feel it inside. but it goes away after you use them for a while. also don't try pulling it out too ealry because it will hurt because it's dry. and never leave it in for a long time.
not its not that bad at all your just to scarred to push the applicatior. and your more than likely feeling it beacuse your dry (like if you dont do it right after you pee or something) and that makes it difficult to full go in correctly. i say stick with pads
and no they dont get stuck up their easy
and get plastic tampons if your going to continue using them