I am sorry you are going through this. I can certainly relate to the 24/7 anxiety as well. I have dealt with this nearly my entire life (I'm 30 now and have dealt with this since I was at least 10 or so, if not younger). I have never been on medication. I have done therapy off-and-on. The first thing I have to say to you is "good job" on getting help and sticking with it. Many people start therapy and don't stick with it and never figure out what is causing the anxiety...and those are the people who continue to have problems more often than not.
I am with you on the medication issue. I, for one, can't handle most medications and have awful side effects on them. I have tried several, out of sheer desperation and my desire to live a normal life, which I have not had up to this point. However, I found that the way I feel on these meds is not the "normal" life I had in mind and my body just can't take them anyways.
What I would suggest is to keep seeing your therapist (whichever one you have the most success with). I don't know if you need to see 2 of them?? As a former therapist myself, I question whether seeing 2 is necessary. For one, as you can see, there are conflicting opionions, each one does therapy differently, and it may get confusing. If you like the one you have been seeing, why not just see that one?
I would also suggest making sure your diet is healthy, taking vitamins (especially B complex...this works amazing for some people--myself included--in mood stabilization, depression, and anxiety). If you don't exercise, start working that in. Again, that is something that I unfortunately do not get to do too often, but I know it works wonders for my panic attacks and anxiety.
Medication can be helpful for some, but if you're not wanting to take it, I would try other avenues first. Have you ever tried anything like accupuncture, yoga therapy, massage therapy, etc.??? I have not tried these things myself, but have had them mentioned to me as therapies that can be helpful.
It does sound like in addition to the anxiety, you have an element of depression in there as well. It sounds like it is a result of all the anxiety, so medication MAY be helpful in getting you through a few months, then discontinuing it when you have things more in order would make sense if you were open to it.
Also, I would focus on becoming independent, getting in some meaningful relationships (friends, partners, etc.)...you had mentioned in your post that your therapist is encouraging you to be independent (great), establishing yourself as an adult (great again), and becoming sexually active...not sure on that one, since if you are engaging in casual sex just to be sexually active, it may not have the effect you want it to have, know what I mean? I'm not saying that is what you are doing, but you had mentioned it as something your therapist was working with you on, so it sounds like that is pretty important to you.
Try not to isolate yourself, try to get involved in some activities that you enjoy or are meaningful to you.
I really hope your situation gets better. Sounds like moving out of your parent's house was a big step in the right direction, and I hope you find peace soon. I honestly do know how awful it is to live with this, and wish you the best.
First off i can totally indentify with what your feeling. I myself have just started to deal with anxiety for the last 3 months, and sometimes its a living hell. And when i dream i feel like my old self, which oddly enough seems to make things worse when i wake up and realize that i am still going through these problems. It all started for me with a simple infection in my lymph nodes in my abdomen that did not resolve for almost a month. Slowly over time the pain resolved but i was left with this feeling that something was wrong with my body and it gave me horrible panic attacks at times, and generalized anxiety and stress all day every day. At first i just tried to deal with it myself because like you i hate the thought of being on medication. However, things just seemed to get worse and started causing pain in different areas of my body mainly my neck and jaw. So, after seeing 5 different specalists and my GP, i ended up taking a small dose of xanax to help reduce the anxiety when i needed it and it helped me to return to a normal life most days. I can tell you that as it stands right now i feel a lot better and it has been almost two weeks since my last panic attack and that the generalized anxiety has been reduced to almost nothing. Im not saying that this is what you need, but it might help you if you dont want to go on the ssri's. So i would suggest talking it over with your doctor and explain your feelings about the meds to them.
I can tell you that somedays it feels as if i was going to be able to beat this, and others i feel as if my brain is broken as well and that i am never going to be my old self again. But i guess thats the boat that we are all stuck in, and have to fight through the bad days to get to the good days. I hope things get better for you and if theres anything that you need to talk about, i have found that the people on this forum are very helpful and compassionate as they are all going through the same things, i know that i am and would be willing to help you if i can.
Hope this helps! :)
PS: It feels kind of like my life has turned into a nightmare. Sometimes In my dreams, I will feel normal, like the old me, and then when I wake up I slowly realize I am waking up back into a nightmare =/ ...kind of like a never-ending anxiety attack.