It hurts so much when we think we are on 100% solid ground with a spouse, and then one day something happens and there is reason to have any qualms, I'm so sorry that you are feeling so low about this.
i would definitely ask to see his phone, and i'd write down numbers and read all texts... he may not let you, I've seen that happen too.
On the other hand, it's a great sign if he willingly will do anything. If it were me, I might think it worth a trip to a marriage counselor, just to let him know that if there is anything going on, then it would be better to get it out in the open now, rather than later.
how did he react when she put thoughts of you being unfaithful into his head?
Thanks everyone for your comment. It's such a relief to know that it's normal to feel the way I'm feeling right now and I'm not overreacting. I just tried talking to my husband and he just kept on saying sorry and told me he regretted it right away after he lied and wanted to tell me the truth. Honestly I don't know what to believe anymore since we've always been the perfect couple in other people's eyes. I know that my husband and this girl don't talk to each other often and they couldn't see each other since we live in Canada and this girl lives in Asia but it's the lying part that hurts me the most.
Exactly SM............there is more to the story indeed.
Being that you have already experienced drama with this friend why would he continue to stay in contact with her behind your back? I would definitely consider this a betrayal especially since she meddled in your relationship between you and your husband before you were married. Good friends DON'T meddle.
If she is just a "buddy," then you as well should know more about her and be ok with interacting with her as well. I am not sure why she was telling your husband then bf that you might be cheating. I would be upset if someone was telling my bf that I may be cheating on him especially if I wasn't.
Your husband keeping this a secret isn't a good thing. I am sure it was to avoid you getting upset, but if he wanted to continue the relationship with this friend he should of smoothed out things between you and her, not try to keep this secret that he is still dealing with this friend who tried to start trouble between you and your husband.
Hi there and welcome. I'm sorry to hear that, So hon, surprise him and ask to see his phone. I don't usually suggest such things because I DO believe in privacy but clearly they are keeping in touch. He knows her birthday? Or was he just saying that?
I would ask him to explain to you why he would jeopardize his relationship with you by communicating with her. She caused major problems. He knows this. And he lied because he knows you would not appreciate his behavior.
I think you need more information. Does he have facebook? Is he communicating with her there? He knows her number to text and truthfully, if I texted someone out of the blue--- they wouldn't know my number that I'd just say a comment on "can you believe it has been so long since high school". You know what I'm saying? there is more to the story.
You need answers. good luck
Hm.
Is it possible this really isn't as big a deal as you believe it to be?
The reason he didn't tell you he texted her is he knew you would be enraged. He knew that, no matter how innocent the birthday wish might be, you would be very angry based on the conversation where she thought you might be cheating a couple years ago.
Since you don't know her, and she was a good friend of his in High School, it doesn't seem unfathomable that she DID think you were cheating on him, and out of loyalty told him so. Who knows what made her think that - a rumor, seeing you out with someone, thinking she saw you out with someone, I don't know. But that's the kind of thing good friends do for each other - if it seems to them the friend is being cheated on, they mention it.
I think I would ask to see the text string. Saying "I can't believe it's been this long since High School" isn't really a very erotic thing to say, and it indicates he hasn't talked to her in a very long time.
The fact that you were so immediately suspicious - and accusatory - is telling.
Do you have good reason to think he's a cheater?