Yes a person can feel hyper symptoms even though they are hypo..it's called "swinging" where you swing from one to the other ( back and forth between hypo and hyper).
Can you find a doctor that treats with blood tests AND how you're feeling?
ALSO...many other issues may be going on here.
Celiacs
Low Iron
Low Iodine
Adrenal Fatigue
and more...
I would definitely get the autoimmune antibody tests run for the Hashimoto's BUT in the end it's just a test and you still will have to make changes in your lifestyle to feel better.
I recommend several things...
a site called WomentoWomen.com this is a site run by female doctors.
also to help you sort out blood work any of the thyroid boards in yahoo ( these people are people just like you, no doctors.)
Keep us posted.
~Amy~
I give up. Would indicate med's to combat hyper symptoms. But if your Dr. is against it I would ask him why. Anxiety may contribute to symptomolgy but I would question why he doesn't think the thyroid is involved with a suppressed TSH. Again I apologize for the mis-information in the first two responses.
I am sorry LUKY I must have been having brain fog. Your TSH is suppressed and is hyper not hypo which would not indicate meds. Would still check out antibodies.
I am not an Endo but it appears that your TSH indicates that you are hypothyroid and would not indicate meds. as they would further supress your TSH. I would check out your thyroid antibodies. If they are increased it may explain hyper symptoms.