I doubt if this is a behavioral problem if you are giving her gummies to make her go, I suggest you cut them back somewhat , the fact she tries to clean herself shows she is trying ,she has a new sister and thats traumatic for a child and a big change in her life, she is now in second place, focus on her positive side and praise her when you see her doing something right, give her some one to one time and ask Dad to do the same.Children dont go to the bathroom to order,try not to reavt negativly as this could exacerbate the problem.