What is the criteria for deciding when a pacemaker is to be replaced? In 1999 I had a pacer implanted after an AV node ablation, indicated for a-fib/ flutter. I am pacemaker dependent. My docs said I had to wait till I was"eri" for a replacement, but the insurance company said I could have one every three years with out a letter of medical necessity. I am anxious to have it replaced due to my dependence: but don't want to rush unnecessarily. To further confuse matters they said the pacer had 3-6 months left in October, but in January they estimated 4-12 months. I also have mild Mitral and Tricuspid regurgitation, mild left atrial enlargement, and mild septal wall motion abnormality consistant with paced rhythm.