What an interesting conversation- I know it's incredibly frustrating to feel as though you are being dismissed by doctors and that your symptoms are somehow in your head. I know I have been there.
Of course, I will face the stigma too, having a dad with bipolar and being a person who has been on antidepressants over the years. Coincidentally, I did my work in therapy and beat an eating disorder and left an unhealthy marriage. I'm so freakin' emotionally well balanced it's just not even funny! :) And I would give anything to have my body cooperate now, so I could just enjoy my life!
I think it's true that it's probably just the way it is that a person will be "required" to rule out emotional/psychological issues for a diagnosis.
It's so good to have each other here to "talk to" though. I think it helps a lot.
That's just it. It's a stigma, that's all. I have experience with alcoholism and bipolar disorder too. I'm not looking to get into an argument of any kind, or to upset David in any way since he's so strongly opposed, but for an alcoholic, whose bipolar and has a severe panic disorder whom now is facing the possibility of a chronic disease needs some sort of professional counselling period. I don't care if you're gay, straight, black or white it's an obvious direction.
JJ is so right too. Anybody who has been to a doc and have been told sx's are all in their head need to get that ruled out. The only way that can be done is by seeing a "shrink"!
JJ
sometimes in the states, the mention of having gone to a shrink in your records is a kiss of death, a stigma that never goes away regardless of the outcome, its like having a wrong diagnosis and no one will remove it!
that and those d....g people are sooooo expensive and want to drag you on for YEARS before saying yea or nay.......
but you make a good point!
I was NOT in any way shape or size saying, implying or even thinking you should see a psych because it was all in your head, hypochondria, psychosomatic or your already dxd mental health issues!
My point was simply, that by getting your mental health assessed for possible causation, you would probably end up having a little peice of paper (diagnostic evidence) stating you'd been fully assessed and in their professional opinion, the sx's you are experiencing are not psychological but physiological and require further investingation.
There is a high proportion of people who end up dx with MS, who have had to get their mental health assessed along the diagnostic journey and have gotten that peice of paper! I had to, not because i've ever had a mental health issue or sx's of but because of my mother and brother's mental health issues, logic not and it su_cked big time, though i do love my peice of paper :o)
I am sorry for your experiences unfortunately its a common story! Look my mum has bipolar and my brother is still an alcoholic and has peripheral neuropathy from pickling his brain for 30 yrs and on top of that he also has Asperger's, seriously I GET IT! You and I could probably debate psychiatry and mental health drugs untill the cows come home, but that isn't the point. btw I am not a particular fan of either to be honest but an issue you still have regardless of your feelings, is that your mental health is being blamed for what you are experiencing now.
The recommedation on getting assessed was not to get medications or therapy, thats your choice to do or not do, it was as i said "to get that turkey off the table" To be perfectly frank, I dont understand why anyone would choose not to find out, to know for sure that mental health as the cause isn't the right dx, if its not, it gets that theory off the table and under the circumstances its pretty important diagnostic evidence!
Your choice is to face it head on or continue to avoid it on prinicpal, and what ever the out come, be comfortable with all the desicions you make.
Cheers..........JJ
ps cheers in Australia is a friendly bye bye :D
I thought they made them stop the big bribe thingy?
I know when I was still in ER nursing, they made them stop doing it for us (darn it, I liked the lunches! ha ha
I'm with you, David, never trust a psychiatrist! Especially with MS
So sorry I wrote with no paragraphs again. I was trying not to do that. Sorry if people had trouble reading.