You will still need to be on the meds for the rest of your life after having you thyroid removed, Can you post your last labs IE Free T3, T4 and TSH Have you had an Ultrasound? My Endo advised the only time he would advise removal is if was blocking the air way, or throat, (Which you said it is) As far as the symptoms, Anxiety/depression etc they can be controlled with medication, which if it is removed you will be on medication (Hormone) treatments for the rest of your life anyway. I would try to keep posting until you have a response from a member that has had thyroid removal and chat with them. Try reposting with "Should I have Thyroid Removed" it may draw a better response. Good Luck FTB4