Above is my comment. Unfortunately, Seventh Generation isn't working. I still have vaginal itching. I then tried Green Forest 100% recycled bathroom tissue. This doesn't work, either. I found this link on Google: https://www.biorelief.com/blog/causes-of-toilet-paper-rash. It recommends an electrical bidet. I don't know if this works, but bidets have been used in France for many years.
I have found that Scott bathroom tissue causes me vaginal itching. I switched to Seventh Generation unbleached recycled bath tissue, 100% recycled bath tissue and the itching is much less. Also, I'm not using soap now in the vaginal area, just a lot of hot and cold water for cleaning. When I ran out of the Seventh Generation Unbleached, I used Scott bath tissue again and the itching resumed badly.
OMG!!! That is happening to me. I was using angel soft. I just switched to Charmin. Look at my Overly Sensitive Vagina Post. Let me know if u find a non-irriating toliet paper. Thanks.
Um, how about you just change your toilet paper and see whether it makes a difference. There is a chance you could possibly have an allergy to something in it.
If changing the toilet paper doesn't work then maybe you should use wet (warm) face washers that have nothing but water on them and see if it fixes it.
Have you personally been treated for thrush because it could also be that.