They like to use Klonopin over Valium because it has some very potent anticonvulsant properties, so does the Tegretol. It's all in the article so I won't go on about it. If you need the rapid action now, so be it. But if and when you do decide to come off, Klonopin is the way to go, especially since you've stated Valium is not an option for you.
Actually there is another take on this using Valium as stated by seamstress. If anyone is interested here is the hyperlink.
http://www.benzodiazepine.org/Taper.html
I guess it all depends on your situation, even the experts seem to have different opinions on this.
Jafco
I went to the doctor today and he agrees to keep me on xanax 2mg 4 times a day. With my asthma, and post heart attact, he does not want to change anything. It was his nurse, who tried without his knowledge to cut me back 2mg per day each week. He said he would call in my medication. I should not take short cuts, but to speak to him. I need the fast action for asthma, but I do not know if I will stay on the xanax for years. Valium bottoms out my mood, but I can take klonopin. I took it for years with good results. Thanks for all the advice.
I am currently detoxing from Xanax - 6 mgs a day habit. I abused it for about 6 years on and off, mostly on. I used to be able to just stop but the last time I tried I started hallucinating and having extreme depersonalization and really weird spasms of whole muscle groups. I was told by a doctor that these were a form of seizures and I was about to have real seizures. Fortunatly for me, I couldn't take it and caved and took some Xanax. A whole handful to be exact which could have been as much as 10 mgs. At that point, I didn't care. It was too scary to continue.
I have since switched to Valium and am at the end of a long valium taper. This is the way to go, trust me. Slow and easy with a long acting benzo. Withdrawl symptoms are minimal and even when they're bad, only last a couple of days. This is the same theory mentioned by jafco re using klonopin except valium is even longer acting.
I have also been diagnosed with BPD, also mild and I am not entirely convinced that it was not mini withdrawls which can produce identical symptoms. Before I abused Xanax, I was an alcoholic and alcohol detox is very similar. I noticed the onset of the rage when I quit drinking. The borderline stuff is manageable without benzos cause I've done it. I am an active person and when I feel one of the episodes coming on, I jog. Unless it's midnight. Then I pace until I wear myself out. It really helps to have a person in your life who will set limits on your behavior. Because if they won't let you go there, you won't. BPD behavior can be very intimidating to some folks as I'm sure you're aware. Which is why it is repeated. It produces a reinforcing effect. But if the person on the receiving end can be tougher or meaner than you, you'll learn real fast that there are other ways to cope. Anyway, as I mentioned I think the wd exacerbates it, so you need to be on top of it before you attempt your taper.
I wish you luck.
The link is good, I just tried it out. Just copy and paste it into your browser and it will work.
Here is how you do that if you don't know already.
Highlight the link that I provided by dragging your mouse over it while holding down the left mouse button.
Then press CTRL C on your keyboard to copy it.
Go to your browser, click where you would normally type the address and press CTRL V to paste it in.
Then press Go or whatever on your browser.
If your typing it in manually, make sure you have not made any typographical errors.
Jafco
I've also been on xanax a long time, doin, an average of 2mg day, I have 75 of the 0.5's would like to be off in a month. The site you posted, I cannot get on. AOL won't accept the address. Any suggestions? Thanks...Nancy
I must have misunderstood. I know they are working for you, they do for me as well, but I thought you wanted to get off this stuff. The reason for changing is that it is much easier to wean yourself off of a longer acting benzo than a shorter acting benzo like Xanax. Your a nurse, so I'm sure you understand about the different half lives of certain drugs. I would imagine you probably know more than I do. I'm by no means an expert, but I have done quite a bit of research into this and it seems to make very good sense.
God Bless
Jafco