I finally attempted to compile an anthology of the answers to PatHC's reflective dissertation, in hopes of developing a new health page for the benefit of all. Well, it helped me immensely to understand what a lousy editor I am. Basically, I copied what I felt were the most helpful posts, adding a comment or two between, and appropriate attribution. Using 14 point type in MS Word (bad coincidence of acronyms, I know), it runs 16 pages. My concerns are several.
First, I don't know if the MedHelp system will handle a health page that large, though I've no reason to believe it wouldn't. We've had some extremely long forum threads, and this is shorter than the thread from which it's taken, I think, though I believe that was a journal rather than the forum.
Secondly, it is one of those things that Lulu warns us about in her thoughtful tips, as it is interminable when one tries to read through it. So much of it is cut & paste, though, that it includes many assorted writing styles; perhaps that would serve to break up the monotony.
Thirdly, I am afraid that the somewhat epistolary style resultant tends to seem rambling, and while it works well for telling an ongoing story (think of "84 Charing Cross Road," if you've ever read that), it provides little structure for a new reader seeking answers, which is what I would hope a health page ought to accomplish. Perhaps this topic is unique in many respects, and this approach would tackle a special topic in a special manner.
Being new at this, should I try to post it as a new health page, and let the flock peck away at it? Should I (can I?) PM it to a few who were active in that thread, and/or our wonderful purple flower ladies? Am I allowed to ask for e-mail addresses (via PM, of course; never post yours in a forum, please) where I could send it for rumination?
Thoughts?